Do I Have to Take a Prosecutor’s Plea?

Kyle Simpson • Aug 22, 2013

Do I Have to Take a Prosecutor’s Plea?

You do not have to accept the plea offer made by the prosecutor handling your case for the County or District Attorney’s office. There are two alternatives available for you to resolve your DWI charge:


1. You can waive your constitutional right to a trial by entering a plea of “Guilty” or “No Contest”. By entering either of these “pleas”, you are agreeing to have the judge find you guilty and assess punishment without having a jury trial.

(Or)

2. You can enter a plea of “Not Guilty” and request a trial by judge or jury.


What is a Plea Bargain?

Due to severe DWI penalties in Texas, you should strongly consider setting your DWI case for trial. Should you decide, however, after consultation with your attorney to enter a “plea” to your DWI, there are two ways you can do so. Before you begin the negotiation process, you need to be familiar with the punishment range associated with your DWI. For example, a DWI (first offense) is a Class B Misdemeanor with a punishment range of 30-180 days in a county jail and up to a $2000.00 fine. If convicted of a DWI (first offense), the punishment you receive will fall within this range. Once sentenced, the judge may “probate” the imposition of the sentence and place you on Community Supervision (Probation). If you are granted probation, you will not have to go to jail in most cases.


A “Plea Bargain Agreement” is essentially a contract between you and the prosecutor. In order to dispose of your case, the prosecutor may offer you a punishment somewhere within the appropriate range to encourage you to accept and enter into an agreement. When submitted to the court, this is called a “plea made pursuant to a plea bargain agreement.” Plea Bargain Agreements are made by defendants to eliminate risk. You may want to agree that probation will be granted in a case that you fear the judge would not otherwise grant it. You may want to agree to reduce the maximum amount of time in jail or prison that you will be exposed to. Although your plea bargain agreement is not binding on the court, you have the right to back out of it should the court not follow it.


You may also enter a plea of “guilty” or “no contest” to the court without a plea bargain agreement with the state. This is considered a plea not made pursuant to a plea bargain agreement, or an “open plea”. If the prosecutor is not willing to agree to the conditions you are requesting in your negotiations, you may enter an open plea and present your arguments to the judge. Under this type of plea, the court may choose to assess punishment anywhere in the appropriate punishment range.

04 Mar, 2024
What to do if you get pulled over for DUI in San Antonio
By Kyle Simpson 16 Nov, 2023
How to Choose a Good San Antonio DWI Lawyer
By Kyle Simpson 16 Nov, 2023
When Can Blood be Forcibly Taken in Texas?
By admin1 21 Sep, 2013
1. Confidence a. Whenever you stand up, stand up like the courtroom is your backyard and you are the expert that will answer all their questions. This requires you to do several things. First, know the law and facts cold. Secondly, dress the part. Wear a nice suit so your first impression is one of ...
By admin1 03 Sep, 2013
Reading a DWI police report can be very misleading. Focusing on what is written by the police officer will always paint a picture of an intoxicated person. A solid DWI defense can frequently be developed with facts not included in the police report but relevant to a thorough DWI investigation. The National Highway Traffic Safety ...
By admin1 01 Sep, 2013
Effective in mid-October, 2011, no one pulled over on suspicion of driving while intoxicated in Bexar County will have the option of refusing both a breath test and blood test to check for the presence of alcohol. If a suspect refuses a breath test, he or she will immediately be slated for a blood draw. ...
By admin1 29 Aug, 2013
Texas law does not allow a court to terminate a DWI probation early. For example, if you are placed on a one year term of Community Supervision Probation and complete all of the conditions (community service hours, classes, court costs, fines…) after eight months, your probation may not be terminated prior to the expiration of ...
By admin1 24 Aug, 2013
If your attorney is able to have your DWI case dismissed, your record will not show a DWI conviction. However, if you do not obtain a Final Order of Expunction, your record will reflect that you were arrested and charged for DWI. The Texas Department of Public Safety is the custodian of criminal records in ...
By admin1 12 Aug, 2013
If the driver of a sedan is pulled over and charged with DWI, it can cause some challenges. The inconvenience of a suspended license, the possibility of jail time, as well as the financial hit caused by hefty fines, the court fees and the increased insurance premiums are all significant consequences that no one wants ...
03 Aug, 2013
The holiday season is a time of merriment and joy, gifts and good times, family and friends coming together. Many of the holiday gatherings of relatives, acquaintances and co-workers around the state have one thing in common: holiday “cheer” in the form of alcoholic beverages. The Texas Department of Public Safety (TDPS) and individual police jurisdictions recognize that eggnog, wine, mulled cider and festive cocktails are a fact of life during the holiday season. That is why they have beefed up patrols on the state’s roads and will man additional sobriety checkpoints in an attempt to catch intoxicated drivers before accidents happen. The TDPS campaign – funded by a grant from the Texas Department of Transportation (TDOT) – will run from December 21 through January 1. It is aimed at keeping drunk drivers off the road during some of the busiest travel days of the year. The federal government is also increasing DUI/DWI enforcement for the Christmas season with its own high profile campaign. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)’s “Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over” campaign is a public safety program that stresses deterrence through education with television commercials, internet ads and print spreads demonstrating the possible criminal ramifications of driving while intoxicated, namely being pulled over and charged with DWI/DUI. If you are pulled over… One of the most important things to remember if you get pulled over for suspicion of DWI in Texas is that you generally have the right to refuse field sobriety or chemical blood tests without a warrant or court order. There might be administrative penalties from your actions, but taking the time to collect your thoughts and speak with an attorney before answering questions or performing tests can make a huge difference in the consequences you might face.  If the DWI is in conjunction with an accident, you have a prior alcohol-related charge on your criminal record or there are children in the car, though, your right of refusal might be revoked. There are also some situations in which the police can compel you to give a breath or blood sample for testing, but requesting a consult with a skilled defense attorney as soon as possible could still help you minimize possible penalties.
More Posts
Share by: